ATG Athens revisited

atg athens july 25 2015 satg athens june 25 2015

Athens is worth another look. Earlier this year we thought that, given the clear a-b-c corrective move from the 471 low, this index had to go down and make a new low. It was at around 800 so it did go down but just a little.

Corrections can take a lot of different forms but the most common is an a-b-c down, a zig-zag. These are 5-3-5 structures and get to there target relatively fast. Often the stock or index has not gone down enough so the exercise is repeated creating a double zig-zag. This can even be repeated a third time, but not more than that. In this particular case the index comes from a little over 6500 and goes to 471. That is roughly 93%. Moreover, the two zig-zags are clearly visible and are perfectly vector equal. It all strongly suggests that the correction is complete. Further support can be derived from the simple observation that between 471 and zero there really is not enough room for another zig-zag.  The 3-wave structure from the lows if that is what it is, of course, argues against this.But that may only be the a wave and now we are in the b with a c to follow perhaps to , say, 2400.  In any event when all is said and done we would favour buying this index.

Fundamentally a stock index represents REAL , not nominal ,  assets. Therefore it is not entirely clear why the value of those real assets should drop any further. Even a default of the Greek government would impact bondholders a lot more and these we understand are 80+% concentrated in the ECB and IMF.  On top of that Greece has only two industries, tourism and shipping. Tourism would get a tremendous boost from drachmas instead of euros and shipping is done mostly in US$$. So even though there will be an initial currency hit, on a slightly longer term basis this might be a real good buy.

S&P, DAX and the FTSE Athens top 20

spx aug 2011

dax aug 2011

athens

The top chart is of the S&P, the one below of the Frankfurt DAX and below that the FTSE Athens top 20. During the fall the S&P lost exactly 50% of its value. The DAX lost 69% and the Athens top 20, 76% Not precisely the same but in the same order of magnitude. Interestingly every single wiggle occurs in all three charts. This relationship holds for the first half of the rebound, then Athens goes its own way. Is it perhaps telling us something??

The SPX and the DAX continue listening to the same drummer except that the DAX is more robust. So far it easily exceeded the B-wave point on the way down, whereas the SPX has failed to make that high.  Concerning the structure, both are undoubtedly working their way up in an A-B-C correction, that is a counter-trend move. In terms of symmetry, both could still forge their way up to the green circle; Athens is obviously complete and perfectly symmetrical. The SPX still has the time and could have one more spurt, perhaps as a thrust from a triangle. That is less likely with the DAX, which has decidedly broken a trend-line and there is no time left and there is no (finished) triangle. Also it would have to regain all the losses which i consider a fairly tall order. ( By the way, the difference in the red and green circles reflects how the individual A and C legs , and the “pause”in the middle are counted ).

Athens is a clear train wreck, and both the SPX and the DAX have outperformed to some degree. Many other markets have been far less robust. Normally one would expect a retracement in the order of 50/62%. The STOXX 50 may represent what is normal best. Here is it’s chart.

Stoxx50 Aug

The yellow area represents the 50 to 62% range. Here too the circle is drawn with a view towards symmetry for the entire corrective structure, it does not show all points where C=A. Here the high occurred 5 months ago in March, which , by the way, was anticipated!

stoxx march5

The 76% retracement is wrongly calculated due to the fact that the chart did not show the top near 4000. The blog can be referenced by going to the March 5th entry, or searching STOXX50.